HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank: Which Ink Tank Printer?

By the Smart Printer team · Updated · 4 min read

Short answer

HP Smart Tank and Epson EcoTank printers both refill from ink bottles, and both makers claim up to 3 years of ink in the box. HP bases its figure on about 167 to 200 pages per month. They differ mainly in bottle design and the companion app. Check the exact model on HP's or Epson's site before you buy.

Two ink tank printers facing each other with a balance scale between them
Contents
  1. What HP Smart Tank and Epson EcoTank have in common
  2. HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank: key differences
  3. Ink, refills and cost
  4. Apps and printing from your phone
  5. How to choose between them
  6. Buying an AirPrint printer?
  7. HP Smart Tank and Epson EcoTank questions

What HP Smart Tank and Epson EcoTank have in common

Both are inkjet lines with built-in ink tanks. You refill them from bottles, so there are no cartridges to replace. Both makers ship the printer with a starter supply of ink and pitch it for people who print often or in volume.

  • Refillable tanks filled from color-matched bottles.
  • Wireless printing from phones and computers.
  • A companion app for setup and ink checks at no cost.
  • Printers sold across a range of models, from basic home units to photo and office versions.

HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank: key differences

The table lists what each maker states on its own site. Details change by model, so use it as a starting point.

HP Smart TankEpson EcoTank
Ink typeTank printer with ink bottlesSupertank printer with ink bottles
RefillingHP describes a no-spill bottle system; bottle caps differ by model seriesEcoFit bottles are keyed so each color fits only its own tank
Ink in the boxHP states up to 3 years of ink for the models it listsEpson states up to 3 years for most users
AppThe HP app (formerly HP Smart) for phones, tablets, Windows and MacEpson Smart Panel for iOS and Android
Phone printingThe HP app; AirPrint and Mopria vary by modelApple AirPrint is listed on current models, plus the Smart Panel app
Cost per pageVaries by model and bottle; see HP's listingsVaries by model and bottle; see Epson's listings

Ink, refills and cost

Both makers say the included ink lasts up to 3 years, based on their own usage assumptions. HP bases its figure on about 167 to 200 pages per month, depending on the model. Treat these as the makers' own estimates for typical use. HP explains the design in What Is a Tank Printer?.

Bottle numbers change by model, so match the label on your bottle or the printer's front door before you order. Our comparison leaves out cost-per-page numbers, because they differ by model and shift over time. Epson describes its range on its EcoTank page.

Apps and printing from your phone

HP's app, which replaced HP Smart, prints and checks ink levels, and HP says it alerts you when it's time to refill. Epson Smart Panel covers printing and ink monitoring. Many models in both lines also work with AirPrint on an iPhone.

How to choose between them

  1. Decide what you print most: documents, photos or both. Look at the photo and office versions in each line.
  2. Open the exact model on HP's or Epson's site and note the ink included, the bottle type and the wireless features.
  3. Check which phone options the model lists: AirPrint, Mopria and the maker's app.
  4. Compare the replacement bottle prices and listed page yields on the maker's page for that model.
  5. Print a test page after setup to confirm every color prints. Our printer test page does that.

Buying an AirPrint printer?

If you mainly print from an iPhone, see which models work with Apple's built-in printing in our AirPrint printers guide. When AirPrint won't cooperate, the print without AirPrint guide shows another way. Apple's About AirPrint page explains how to check a model.

What to remember

  • Both lines use refillable ink tanks filled from bottles.
  • Both makers claim up to 3 years of ink in the box.
  • Specs and bottle prices vary by model, so check the exact printer.
  • Either printer can print from an iPhone over Wi-Fi.

HP Smart Tank and Epson EcoTank questions

How does refilling compare in HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank?

Both use ink bottles that match each tank's color. Epson's EcoFit bottles are keyed to fit only the right tank. HP's bottle caps vary by series, so follow the guide for your model.

Does the HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank choice matter for iPhone printing?

Not much. Both makers have iPhone apps, and many models in both lines support AirPrint.

How much ink comes in the box in HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank?

Each maker claims up to 3 years of ink for typical use, depending on the model. The page yield differs between models, so read the listing for yours.

Which costs less per page in HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank?

It depends on the model and bottle. Compare the replacement bottle price and the listed page yield on HP's or Epson's page for the exact printer.

Do HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank printers use cartridges?

No. Both are inkjet lines with built-in ink tanks that you refill from bottles, so there are no cartridges to replace.

What apps support phone printing in HP Smart Tank vs Epson EcoTank?

HP's app, which replaced HP Smart, prints and checks ink levels. Epson Smart Panel covers printing and ink monitoring.

Whichever tank you pick, print from your phone

Smart Printer finds HP and Epson printers on your Wi-Fi and prints photos and documents from your iPhone.

Print from my tank printer
Scan to get it on your iPhone

4.0500 ratingsFree download. PRO is billed by Apple inside the app.

Smart Printer home screen with web pages, documents, email and camera